No Shit, Sherlock
The rain in suburban Melbourne didn't fall so much as it hung in the air like a damp, miserable blanket. Inside the unmarked Holden Commodore parked outside the Waverley Cemetery gates, the heater was broken, the windscreen wipers squeaked in a rhythm that bordered on psychological torture, and Detective Senior Constable Lachlan Vance was three minutes away from eating his own badge.
Spread across his lap were the case files for the "Eastern Suburbs Strangler"—a moniker the local press had cooked up despite the fact that only two people had been killed, and neither of them had actually been strangled. Both victims had been bludgeoned with what forensics tentatively identified as a heavy brass candlestick, making it less of a gritty modern thriller and more of a tragic game of Cluedo.
"Focus, Lockie," Lachlan muttered to himself, squinting at a blurry crime scene photograph. "Timeline. Victim one, Tuesday night. Victim two, Friday morning. Both had memberships to the Glen Waverley Bowls Club. There's a connection here."
Beside him, in the passenger seat, Detective Senior Constable Toby Miller was not looking at the files. Toby had his eyes squeezed shut so tightly his eyebrows were touching his hairline. His fingertips were pressed against his temples, and he was humming a low, resonant mmm sound that vibrated through the centre console.
Lachlan didn't look up. "Toby."
"Mmmmmmm."
"Toby, stop humming. You sound like a faulty fridge."
"Shh," Toby whispered, raising one index finger without opening his eyes. "The ether is thick today, Lachlan. The veil is thinning. I'm tuning into the killer's frequency. He's... he's angry. He feels misunderstood."
"He's bludgeoning retirees with antique homewares, Toby. 'Misunderstood' isn't going to hold up at the Magistrates' Court." Lachlan slapped the manila folder shut and tossed it onto the dashboard. "We're burning daylight. Our prime suspect's alibi puts him at his mother's grave around the time of the second murder, and the groundskeeper says he saw someone matching his description hanging around the eastern lawn this morning. Let's go."
Toby’s eyes snapped open. He looked entirely too pleased with himself. "I knew it. I was just about to say 'cemetery.' The spirits were practically shouting it at me."
"We are parked directly outside the cemetery gates, Toby. You read the sign when we pulled up."
"A sign is just a physical manifestation of a spiritual nudge, mate." Toby unbuckled his seatbelt, shifting his heavy trench coat so the deep inner pocket didn't clank against the door frame. "Besides, it wasn't a candlestick. Not a standard dining one, anyway. More of an altar piece. Heavy base, tarnished brass, slight dent on the lip from the second swing."
Lachlan paused with his hand on the door handle, frowning. "Forensics hasn't released the weight or shape analysis yet. How'd you come up with that?"
Toby tapped the side of his nose, smiling serenely. "Psychic imprint, Lockie. The metal screams when it strikes bone."
Lachlan sighed, popped the door handle, and stepped out into the drizzle, flipping his collar up against the chill. Toby followed, taking a deep, theatrical breath of the damp air as they walked past the wrought-iron gates and onto the gravel path winding between rows of weathered marble headstones and sagging angels.
Toby immediately slowed his pace, holding his hands out at waist height, palms down, as if testing the temperature of an invisible swimming pool. He frowned, tilting his head toward the sky.
"Hold on," Toby said, stopping dead in the middle of the path. "Stop. Don't move."
Lachlan halted, turning back with his hands jammed deep into his coat pockets. "What? Did you see him?"
"No. Worse." Toby closed his eyes again, his brow furrowing with immense, theatrical strain. "The energy here is... overwhelming. Heavy. Cold. Lachlan, I'm getting a massive psychic hit. I sense we're surrounded by dead people."
Lachlan stared at him. A single drop of water ran off the tip of Lachlan's nose. He looked left at a granite obelisk from 1924. He looked right at a row of freshly laid memorial plaques. He looked back at his partner.
"No shit, Sherlock," Lachlan deadpanned. "We're in a cemetery!"
"You can't rush the process, Lockie," Toby said smoothly, completely unfazed as he resumed his slow, sweeping hand motions. "The psychic radar picks up everything first. You have to filter out the background noise to find the killer's aura. Keep walking. Let the spirits guide us."
"The spirits aren't guiding us, Toby, the gravel path is. The groundskeeper said the eastern lawn is straight ahead."
"Honestly, those two blokes from the bowls club had terrible auras anyway," Toby mused casually as they walked. "Real smug energy. The type of blokes who cheat at lawn bowls and brag about their investment properties at the bistro. Honestly, if someone were to sneak up behind them in the carpark with a heavy blunt object, you could almost see why the universe balanced the scales."
"You're a real humanitarian, Toby."
They rounded a bend lined with dense cypress trees, the crunch of their boots muffled by the damp earth. Ahead of them, under a sprawling canopy of black umbrellas, a small crowd of about thirty people stood huddled together in solemn silence. A classic hearse was parked on the narrow tarmac lane nearby, and at the centre of the gathering, a priest in damp black vestments was reading softly from a leather-bound book.
Lachlan immediately slowed down, lowering his voice to a respectful murmur. "Alright, detour. There's a service going on. Let's cut wide around the hedges so we don't disturb them."
Toby didn't listen. His head snapped toward the gathering, his eyes widening as if he had just witnessed a bolt of lightning strike a flagpole. Before Lachlan could grab his sleeve, Toby strode purposefully across the wet grass, heading straight toward the back of the mourners.
"Toby, get back here!" Lachlan hissed, speed-walking after him in a frantic, low-profile crouch that achieved nothing except making him look like a man desperately searching for a dropped contact lens.
Toby didn't stop until he was standing right at the edge of the crowd, peering around the shoulder of a weeping woman in a black trench coat. Lachlan skidded to a halt beside him, grabbing Toby’s elbow, ready to drag him backward into the bushes.
Before Lachlan could pull, Toby gasped. He knelt down, dramatically pressing both palms flat against the wet grass just inches from a towering pile of excavated dirt and a gleaming mahogany coffin resting on lowering straps.
"Incredible," Toby breathed, loud enough to carry cleanly over the priest's quiet prayer. "The psychic resonance here is off the charts. Lachlan, come feel this. I sense the earth is freshly disturbed."
Every single head under the black umbrellas turned in unison. The weeping woman in the trench coat froze mid-sob. A large man in a tailored charcoal suit stared at Toby with naked hostility.
Lachlan looked down at the massive mound of brown dirt. He looked at the open rectangular hole in the ground. He looked at the coffin. Then he looked at the priest, who had stopped reading entirely and was staring over his spectacles at the two men in cheap suits crouching by the grave.
Lachlan slowly stood up, letting go of Toby's arm. He offered the mourners a tight, apologetic grimace, then leaned slightly toward the priest.
"Excuse me, Father," Lachlan whispered, pitching his voice just low enough that only the clergyman could hear. "Quick word?"
The priest blinked, glanced at the grieving widow, and took one cautious step away from the lectern. "My son, we are in the middle of a committal—"
Lachlan reached into his back pocket, pulled out his wallet, and extracted a crisp twenty-dollar note. He held it out discreetly at waist level. "I'll give you twenty bucks to bury him with the deceased."
The priest stared at the twenty, then up at Lachlan’s dead-eyed expression, then back down at Toby, who was now sniffing the dirt mound like a bloodhound.
"No," the priest said firmly. "Absolutely not. That is illegal and deeply sacrilegious."
"Fair enough," Lachlan said, not missing a beat. He reached back into his wallet, pulled out another twenty and a ten, and fanned them out. "Fifty. Nobody has to know. Just roll him in when the straps go down. I'll help with the shovel."
"Officer—assuming you are an officer—please leave before I call the police," the priest hissed.
Before Lachlan could respond, Toby stood up, brushing mud onto his trousers, and clapped a heavy, sympathetic hand on the shoulder of the large man in the charcoal suit.
"I'm getting a strong message from the departed," Toby announced loudly to the entire gathering. "He wants you all to know he's fine, though he's a bit annoyed about the catering choice for the wake. Did someone order egg sandwiches? He's saying 'tell Brenda to throw out the egg sandwiches, they're turning.'"
At the front of the crowd, an elderly woman in a black veil gasped. "I made those sandwiches!"
"And frankly, Brenda, the mayonnaise is a cry for help," Toby added warmly. "I'm just the messenger."
The large man in the charcoal suit clenched his fists, his neck turning a dangerous shade of purple. Several other mourners began muttering furiously, stepping forward.
The priest watched the widow burst into fresh, horrified tears, watched the man in the charcoal suit wind up a right hook, and looked back at Lachlan.
The priest let out a long, slow breath. "Make it a hundred."
Lachlan didn't even blink. He pulled two more twenties and a ten from his wallet, slapped the hundred dollars cleanly into the priest's palm, and stepped back toward the cypress trees as the charcoal-suited man lunged forward.
Two hours later, the rain had finally stopped, leaving the late afternoon sun to slant weakly through the stained-glass windows of St. Jude’s Catholic Church. The sanctuary was quiet, save for the faint echo of footsteps on stone tiles and the quiet creak of a heavy oak door swinging shut.
Inside the cramped, dimly lit confessional booth, Lachlan sat on the small wooden bench, staring at the lattice screen separating him from the other side. He rested his elbows on his knees, steepled his fingers, and let out a long, steady breath.
After a moment, the small wooden shutter slid open with a sharp clack.
"Bless me, Father, for I have sinned," Lachlan said calmly into the grille. "It has been... well, quite a while since my last confession."
From the shadows on the other side of the screen came a familiar, weary sigh. "Go ahead, my son. The Lord is listening."
"I paid a man of the cloth a hundred dollars to bury my ex-partner alive."
Silence hung in the tiny wooden box for three full seconds.
Then, the shadow shifted. Father O'Malley turned his head directly toward the lattice screen, his profile dimly illuminated by the light filtering through the booth's curtain.
"My son," Father O'Malley said, his voice rich with absolute certainty and profound peace. "You killed no one today. What happened in that cemetery was entirely God's will."
Lachlan raised an eyebrow. "Is that right, Father?"
"Undoubtedly," the priest replied smoothly. "The Lord works in mysterious ways, and He grants each of His children the exact gifts they need to survive their trials. If God had wanted that bumbling idiot to live, He would have given him the ability to dig his way out."
Father O'Malley paused, his eyes narrowing thoughtfully behind the lattice as he studied Lachlan's face.
"Besides," the priest continued, lowering his voice to a conspiratorial murmur, "if I may make a confession of my own, Detective... I'd actually seen your bumbling buffoon of a partner before today."
Lachlan frowned, leaning closer to the grille. "You have? Where?"
"Out at Waverley, on the eastern lawn, just this morning," Father O'Malley said calmly. "I was blessing a headstone two rows over when I saw him lingering beside his mother's grave—Margaret Miller, lovely woman, passed two winters ago. Only he wasn't laying flowers, my son. He was wiping blood off one of my missing solid-brass altar candlesticks before stuffing it back into his trench coat."
Lachlan froze. His jaw dropped slightly as the pieces clicked together in rapid succession—the bowls club rivalries, the exact dent on the lip of the murder weapon, the witness sighting on the eastern lawn.
"Son of a bitch," Lachlan breathed. "He was the Eastern Suburbs Strangler."
"Was," Father O'Malley corrected gently, offering a serene smile through the screen. "As I said, Detective—the Lord works in mysterious ways. You didn't just save a funeral today; you saved the taxpayers a fortune in court costs."
Lachlan stared at the priest for a beat, then let out a slow, incredulous laugh, leaning back against the oak panelling. "You know, Father, I think I feel absolved already."
"Go in peace, my son."
Lachlan reached through the small gap beneath the wooden lattice screen, extending a closed fist. On the other side, Father O'Malley didn't hesitate, sliding his own hand forward to meet it.
Their knuckles tapped together with a quiet, solid thud right through the confessional wall.

Comments